Fake Daddies vs Real Doms: Red Flags Every Submissive Should Know

By GoodGirlTara 546 views 24th Apr 2026

Seller

Fake Daddies vs Real Doms: Red Flags Every Submissive Should Know

Hey sweeties! It’s your favourite submissive MILF here and today I want to share something that happened to me recently — not to vent, but to help protect other girls who are newer to this world or still figuring out their boundaries.

I had a guy message me acting like the ultimate dominant Daddy. You know the type: heavy “I’ll tell you when you’re allowed to see me naked,” “you’ll get your turn when I say so,” and lots of bossy demands right from the start. He wanted to “see how I operate” before paying for anything.

At first I played along sweetly (because that’s part of the fun when it’s done right), but things quickly went downhill. When I calmly asked for the tip for a proper dick rating, he got pushy, demanded more “composure” from me and then threw out a weak “you’re being a good whore for me” like it was supposed to fix everything.

When I gently pointed out what real dominance actually looks like, his final reply was just “TOO BAD” and a shrug emoji.

Diary entry material, right? But more importantly — it’s a perfect teaching moment.

Here are the big red flags I spotted (and that you should watch for too):

Demands free submission or “testing” before paying
Real Doms understand that your time, emotional labour and experience have value. If he wants you to obey, role-play or perform without tipping first, that’s not dominance — it’s entitlement. A serious client shows respect by paying for your service upfront.
All control, zero praise
This guy had zero idea how a praise kink works. A skilled Dom mixes bossy commands with warm, genuine “good girl” energy that makes you feel safe and eager to please. Constant demands without any positive reinforcement just feels cold and exhausting.
Gets angry or defensive when you set boundaries
The moment I asked for payment, he switched to all-caps and aggression (“I just fucking told you… UNDERSTOOD?!”). Real dominants respect boundaries. Fake ones throw tantrums when you don’t instantly submit for free.
“I need more composure from you” type criticism
Early criticism of your responses (especially when you’ve been polite and professional) is a huge red flag. It’s often a way to test how much they can push you around emotionally.
Strong on worn items, weak on actual domination
If he has good reviews for simple transactions (panties, socks, etc.) but struggles the second real power exchange or chat comes in, be extra careful. Quick purchases don’t require emotional intelligence or skill.
No real negotiation or aftercare awareness
Good Doms check in, build tension slowly and make sure you’re comfortable. Fake ones jump straight to “I’m in charge” without any warmup or care.

What I wish I’d known earlier (and what I tell every newer sub now):

Trust your gut. If something feels off or boring instead of exciting, it probably is.
Your experience is valuable — never let someone make you feel like you have to “prove” you’re a good submissive by working for free.
A real Daddy earns your submission. He doesn’t demand it while refusing to invest anything himself.
It’s okay to end the conversation politely and move on. You don’t owe anyone free emotional labour or endless chances.

In the end, I told him calmly:

“Understood. But a real Daddy who knows how to lead doesn’t demand composure and free obedience while testing me. He earns it with respect and proper praise that actually makes a girl want to submit. I’d happily train you to be a proper Daddy if you were serious… but right now you’re just playing at it. I think we’re done here. Take care.”

His shrug response told me everything I needed to know.

So here’s my advice to all my fellow submissive girls out there (especially if you’re newer or still building your confidence):

Don’t settle for loud “Dom” energy that doesn’t feel good. Hold out for the ones who mix control with genuine praise, who respect your rates and who make you feel safe and desired. Those Daddies exist — and when you find them, the dynamic is so much hotter.

If you’re reading this and thinking “that sounds like the guy I’m talking to right now,” trust yourself. Block, mute or politely exit. Your time and energy are precious.

Have you encountered any of these red flags? Drop your stories or questions in the comments — I read them all and I’m always happy to chat or give more specific advice.

Stay safe, stay bratty when you need to and never forget your worth.

Join us for free and start your journey!

By GoodGirlTara

not for everyone… and I like it that way 🤍 soft, submissive… but only for the right person. I don’t give my attention easily. I don’t open up for just anyone. but...

View Profile >

Interested in contributing to our awesome community blog? Why not get in touch with our friendly team?

Comments

WetNsmelly86 @MistressValkyrieBR if you don't read and learn about it. You can do some real mental or physical harm. Aftercare is important and please do research

MistressValkyrieBR I tried to reply to your message but I can't! As for the platform you asked about, you have to upload to DRIVE and post links there... you have to read the rules; sometimes they're strict and ban a lot of things, but sometimes they let things slide. But I've already lost an account (back when I didn't know how to disguise my content) with over 30 paying subscribers. If you know how to work the platform, you’ll go far.

WetNsmelly86 I love your shirt in your pfp

LillyLollyPop I had one man accidentally become my dominant through exactly this. Respect, curiosity, working together to find what feels best and humour! There is something so dehumanising about sitting there having orders barked at you, even in a paid for service! As you say, it's so much hotter if you take your time and make me WANT to submit 💞 Fabulous blog 💞

Cassie1994 👏🏼 👏🏼 Such a good blog and definitely worth the read!! Thanks for writing. 🩷

MissCataleya @BeardedBelgian 100%

MistressValkyrieBR I’m working on becoming a good dominatrix; I post videos (anime images) on Patreon, and my audience consists of submissives. But I have to admit I’m afraid I’ll end up being a terrible dominatrix—that I’ll come across as insensitive for mixing in total humiliation just because some people like it, even though not everyone is looking for that. I hope I don’t turn out to be a total bitch one day.

Petite_Princess @Alexibun This has largely been my experience, definitely not subs the way some have spoken to me. 😅

BeardedBelgian I can definitely relate to this! The red flags you mentioned give me the ick too. Being a Dom is not about yelling insults and treating subs like trash... It's about subtle mindgames, having attention to detail and knowing what triggers a subs kinks. During my pleasure dom days I would take notes first, set boundaries and create whole sexting scenarios. Trust and respect are important

OliviaLane Congrats on the blog. Awesome

Alexibun @Petite_Princess Lots RP subs as I call them, they like the idea but don't actually want to give up control.

Petite_Princess This blog is an absolute gem. Oddly enough I've had similar encounters but with people saying they're subs/cucks, but as with your experience, these individuals didn't seem to know how to enact the role they claimed to have. x

AutumnWolf @GoodGirlTara communication & Boundaries comes before aftercare. If you haven't communicated about aftercare you can't guarantee to get it. Let alone get the right aftercare that is needed/wanted for your sub space. Not every sub is the same. Also Aftercare goes both ways and sometimes the Dom requires aftercare to help with the Dom drop. X

Phasic @Curvy_Amelia it's all about the vibes they give off. You learn to spot them and just like in this blog trust your gut feeling and learn the red flags

GoodGirlTara @XRubyRed sad to say that I've met a few nasty ones on here. I'm so willing to try and educate but it just doesn't go in.

BustyLily1 @Eyeroll Had a feeling you’d notice that 😉

GoodGirlTara @Eyeroll it's all about the aftercare!

GoodGirlTara @GingerRuby I mean, wow, thanks 😘

BustyLily1 @Eyeroll Agreed!

GoodGirlTara @BustyLily1 soooo true.

GoodGirlTara @Miss_Belle thanks for that. It was probably as much of a culture shock as it was for me trying to be a domme! 😂

Alabamagrrl Hell yeah! This all needed to be said! 💕

Chocolate_Milf I became a Domina after a slew of disappointing fake "daddies"... if you want something done right, do it yourself lol

Phasic @XRubyRed thanks for raising awareness over bad subs. They drain my social battery more than anyone. They are a nuissance and give me the ick

XRubyRed Another important follow-up is how to spot fake subs, especially as a seller here! Fake subs can be just as toxic and abusive as fake Doms, and they can really break the motivation of good Doms.

XRubyRed I love this! This topic is so important to have discussions about and raise awareness. I’ve seen a lot of people fall victim to “Doms” who are just nasty people who want to abuse others under the guise of BDSM. Thanks for writing this!

Eyeroll 9/10 people claiming to be a dom on here have never even heard the word aftercare 🤣🤣

Curvy_Amelia Great read and useful not only for Sub/Dom relationship, but in general. Girls ! Never provide content before payment ! I'm sorry, if I offended someone, but we are here to sell ,not to entertain kinks for free ❤️

GingerRuby Best article this year!

Bunn13ie this!

Spicy_Pleasure Thank you GoodGirlTara I’m so happy to read this! But unfortunately, it's not limited to sub/daddy relationships. I've recently had several unpleasant experiences with sissies and substances who either get angry or ghost you as soon as you make it clear that it's not free. I get the impression that most profiles are just there for fantasizing and that many reviews are fake… 😉

Eyeroll @BustyLily1 you and your hills 😂😂

MissCataleya Very useful advices! 😊 Also for Doms. The fact we go for Dom/Sub relation, doesnt mean you are allowed to disrespect it. I found it hard for many "Doms" to arrange a deal and settle things. It stops on "Im a DOM". Ok, and what next?

Alexibun I used to screen 'doms' for a submissive seller friend here. Most were honestly a joke and I told them to read up on consent, power exchanges, etc. before approaching anyone else. 🙄

BrattyGinger Such a good read, and very valid points for personal life experiences too! Good behavior is rewarded with praise, snacks, cuddles etc. some of these “daddies” here (no capitalization bc these ones don’t deserve it) just wanna degrade women for free and it’s so exhausting and insulting due to the nature of this site is obviously pay for play. Set those boundaries ladies and stick to em 🩶

BustyLily1 This is so true, I can spot a fake a mile off. True dominance doesn’t need to shout, I’ll die on this hill

Dahliadivinity Another great tip, just taking onto the “trust your gut” feeling… if it doesn’t feel right for YOU, that is also ok! You don’t have to have a reason other than you’re not feeling it. Doesn’t mean anything is wrong with either party, and there’s no need to feel guilty for saying “no.” Much love to my subbies!!!

Phasic All of this is absolutely true. A lovely read and thank you for your perspective

AutumnWolf I found there's not many real Dom's/Daddy Dom's on here

Miss_Belle Interesting…a few months ago I was approached to be a sub and I said no because I’m not submissive and he said let’s try and I had a large amount of money sent to me… then had to perform tasks… all very polite with a little praise and then he’d switch to being abrupt with me again… I didn’t quite understand it but your blog has made me understand more… thank you xx